Showing posts with label Legal System. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Legal System. Show all posts

Monday, May 17, 2010

W.T. F. - Can We Please Stop The Bloodshed!








By Susan Murphy-Milano


As I sip my coffee with cream, pecking away on my computer, reading the bloodshed in the headlines, I am split between those whom you will never read about because they got out of their abusive and violent relationships, and those whose permanent residence is now in a cemetery, their violent lives marked by a single headstone tablet coldly displaying the name, date of birth through the date they died.


There are many mothers and their children who are living their lives without violence because they had a plan to get out of their toxic and abusive relationship. Some enlisted an army of friends, neighbors and relatives, others, by shear will and determination, got out, but you will not ever read about them, they are safe. Some packed their bags and made a new life for themselves across country, others did not stray very far from familiar territory and yet were still able to rebuild their lives.

So why are we seeing bloodshed at epidemic proportions? What are those victims who are being killed doing wrong? And what are those who remain alive doing correctly?

Are the women who are murdered along with their children assisted by a society of pure ignorance when it pertains to domestic violence and intimate partner homicide? Look around folks, you cannot pick up a paper or turn on the news without hearing how another woman was murdered by someone they new intimately. You can't help but read nasty comments on the internet, not from strangers, but, often by friends and realtives who knew both the victim and the abuser, trying to defend the actions of a cold blooded killer, and blaming a victim because she filed for divorce or took the children. Has anyone ever asked the question, "why?" Or is it easier to turn our backs and call victims liars or drama queens even after they or their innocent children are murdered? The phrase "shame on you" (I have a different phase more along the lines W.T.F. but I cannot use it here) to all Americans comes to mind especially when I know in 80% of these tragedies the victims did not have to die. They would still be alive if not for human ignorance. I do not have enough posts to list all those who are dead, but, if I did, it would surpass those killed in both the Vietnam and Iraq war combined.

American soldiers are properly trained and given weapons as they fight and go into battle for our country. Victims of violence during their battle are often given little more then lip service from the legal system and society.


For those who got out of the stalking and domestic violence relationships, do not think for one minute they have or had it easy. These victims swallowed their dose of being beaten and raped within an inch of their lives, not knowing from one moment to the next what their abuser or former partner was going to do to them or their children. Somehow they made it through to see a new sunrise the next morning, and many began, after the beatings and verbal threats against them, a plan to exist in their toxic environments with their lives. It was not easy as many of these women who came and tried before them did not make it and let's remember where those victims are, dead. But, many abuse victims who are now alive had help, be it a shelter for women, a church, an attorney who took favor on them representing them in their divorce or custody case for little or no charge. Or in some situations, they were able to get hold of advocates like me.


With all my heart and soul I would like to believe that someone is listening. Someone cares about the number of murders wreaking havoc in America on the lives of innocent victims of violence, not always women, men too, and are ready to be part of a revolution demanding that the victims of this war be given a level playing field to fight and stay alive. I, for one, am tired of singing in a choir where the lives of victims murdered out weighs the millions of Americans' who are able to be a voice and sing loudly for effective change.





Been there, done that…” Susan Murphy- Milano has turned a tired phrase into demonstrable realism through the gift of her newly published book, "TIME'S UP: A GUIDE ON HOW TO LEAVE AND SURVIVE ABUSIVE AND STALKING RELATIONSHIPS

Thursday, January 14, 2010

Legal System For Victims of Family Violence is Like Shattered Glass


By Susan Murphy Milano


Most of us who hear stories on the news about domestic violence tend to think in terms of a “single incident” or, a “one time only” act of violence. Or at times we hear others question and blame victims for being involved in these types of dangerous sitations. But we must understand that the world in which these "victims" live, is often no different than captured and tortured prisioners of war. The vanished, the missing, the murdered all were calculated and planned out by an abusive, angry and controlling individual.


 The term “DOMESTIC VIOLENCE” is a continuing pattern of behavior which can include : repeated harassment, stalking or surveillance of the victim,' threats and intimidation, bodily harm, sexual assault, child abduction or the constant threat , that can escalate, in some cases to murder . In most abuse cases, the danger continues despite the victim’s attempts to get help from traditional sources. For example, after a battered woman seeks assistance from the courts or separates from her abuser, she statistically runs a greater risk of increased harm. The abuser is furious, and steps up his behavior and violent attacks. And often the victim is left to fend for herself when it comes to protecting her life. 


 Local shelters play an important role in not only providing a safe place to go, but many victims are unaware that shelters also assist victims in obtaining orders of protection, counseling and legal assistance. To visit them on the web: http://www.ncadv.org or their tool free number is 1-800-799-SAFE. The phones are answered twenty-four hours a day, seven days a week. 


 Many women are victims of chronic abuse. They have been threatened with repeated violence or even death. Victim’s are no stranger to the court system, they have often waded through stacks of police reports, orders of protection filings and numerous criminal complaints. They have spent long hours in the courtroom seeking protection through the legal system. And with each step a victim takes, in some situations, their abusers have become increasingly violent toward them. 


As a society, we still sweep the issue of domestic violence aside, like disposable garbage. I hear comments all the time “why can’t she just leave” or “ she must have done something to provoke his behavior.” No one drives anyone to commit acts of violence and terror. The abusers do this because society has allowed them to get away with their behavior of power and control. 


We have come a long way when it comes to drinking and driving. Laws across the country, are strict and often severe in nature. A person found guilty of drinking and driving no longer gets off with a slap on the wrists. They do serious jail time for this crime. 


Why are we unable to do apply the same logic when it comes to Domestic Violence? 


Is it because we think off it as a private matter between two consenting adults? Drinking used to be a private matter, involving consenting adults, until people started getting killed, then organizations fought hard to get tough legislation passed. There has been tough legislation passed over the years on abuse and stalking related crimes by organizations across the county. It is no longer enough. Technology has assisted the abusers in their efforts to control and harass their prey.


As you read the tragedies with your morning coffee, realize, more must be implemented to assist victims in leaving safely.


Current laws were not signed by elected officials with a pen of ink, but with a pen of blood, of all those who lost their lives.

Monday, January 4, 2010

People Perish for Lack of Knowledge


By Charles Moncrief

These words from Hosea 4:6 were originally addressed to a people in a religious context. Taken in a vacuum, these words are applicable in our time -- especially when the result of ignorance has tragic consequences.

For an example, here is the opening paragraph of Susan Murphy-Milano’s journal entry.

It was two days after Christmas and 18 days after the ink barely dry on the divorce papers when, Matthew Schneider stormed into the home of his ex-wife [Brandy] as their 8year-old watched when "daddy" shot Mom and her new boyfriend multiple times before turning the gun on himself.

Brandy had filed for divorce from Matthew in April, even though Matthew had threatened to kill her. Her pleas for protection either went unheeded or resulted in tragically inadequate criminal action.

What can we learn from Brandy’s tragedy? Where did the legal system fail? Realistically, we should ask a different question: Where did the legal system fail this time?

Matthew Schneider spent the first year of their son’s life in prison because he had beaten Brandy severely, at least once while she was pregnant. Matthew was a juvenile sex offender, a convicted felon, and under house arrest at the time of the incident. He had made threats to kill Brandy if she divorced him. He had made harassing, and perhaps threatening, phone calls to Brandy following the divorce. And he possessed at least one firearm.

While this tragedy may have been preventable, my purpose is not to complain about the system’s failure. I’d rather address some misconceptions we may have about our nation’s legal system.

First, however, let me give a disclaimer. Please seek competent legal advice for any action you take after reading this. Nothing here is intended for any purpose other than to disclose facts, though they may betray a certain cynicism on my part.

Divorce cases are civil matters. The specifics of civil cases, such as details of the outcome and the proceedings themselves, are often placed under a gag order. So the evidence, rulings on admissibility, and testimony, remains unknown. To speak later about the case is to risk a contempt citation. This gives us two important clues that more can be done.

First, the operative word is "later." Critical documents and other materials gathered for presentation should be recorded privately as soon as the decision is made to proceed in the civil courts. In Brandy’s case hospital records, the prior criminal proceedings against Mathew, as much detail as possible describing the path to be taken (photographs, diagrams, grounds, names of parties, witness information, evidence to be presented, relief sought, etc.), and any other material should be made safe and a chain of possession established. One way to do this is to mail the documents, with a clear date-dime stamp from the Post Office, to a trusted friend or other person not involved in the case. This person must keep the container sealed until needed. These materials are exempt from any court ruling against disclosure, since the judge’s contempt power cannot reach the recipient of US Mail who has no standing in the case. The judge’s contempt power cannot reach backward in time either, making a readable date-time stamp absolutely imperative.

The next operative word is "gag." Not everything about a civil case can be gagged, and the gag can usually be lifted in a criminal case or by a civil appeals court. Examples of items not gagged are case ID (number and name), court, judge, and counsel. All of these are public record and subject to open disclosure.

Disclosure is the key to this article. Most people know very little of the recourse available following an unjust outcome or inappropriate proceedings in a court case. If a judge misbehaves or issues an inappropriate ruling, including a contempt citation, a person can file a complaint with the state’s commission on judicial conduct. Whatever the official name of the commission from one state to another, the purpose is the same: to allow a private citizen a measure of recourse against a defective judge. Any citizen can file a complaint with this commission for little or no cost, and that person need not have any standing in the case involved. Immediately the non-gagged items become useful. The citizen has the right to demand that the commission assign a case number to the complaint and to proceed with an official investigation. The least that occurs following such a complaint is that the judge must make an official response to the commission, and the complainant is exempt from any retaliation by the judge. And depending on the findings of the commission, action against the judge may be of benefit to all of society.

This should go without saying, but apparently it is not obvious so I’ll include some warnings.
  • DO NOT approach the commission on judicial conduct until the case is closed. An angry judge is not a good thing to trust.
  • DO NOT let your emotions direct your actions. Be at least strongly convinced that the judge did act inappropriately and not just in a manner that offended you. To proceed in good faith will protect you from legal action if your complaint seems frivolous.
  • DO NOT write anything containing slander or libel about the judge. And while you cannot write about the detailed proceedings, you can mention in your call for investigation that a gagged item bears scrutiny.
  • DOCUMENT your actions outside of the system. The judge cannot legal recourse, but social and unofficial retaliation can occur. This is not about secret police or midnight fire-bombings; it’s more like casual comments to your employer, to HR when you apply for a job, or a blackball if you run for office in the Rotary Club.
  • Depending on the level of fear you may have about retaliation, you may want to notify the attorney general and local news media. Then if anything does happen, records are on file.
Note that if you file a complaint with the commission, it may have no apparent effect as far as you are concerned. But you establish a history for that judge. When the next person issues a complaint, the presence of previous action will be considered at least subjectively. The judge must then respond not only to the complaint itself, but to the repetitive nature as well.

The same sort of recourse is available against an attorney, though it’s more likely that the complainant must have standing in the case. Every attorney is a member of a local and perhaps a state bar association, and any person directly affected by an attorney’s misbehavior has the right to complain to the bar and request an investigatory hearing. Again, please avoid frivolity and emotion. And recognize that the course of any investigation will include an attempt to make you look and feel like the slime of the earth. It’s merely procedural, and it should not be taken personally. The slime is the system, not you.

I want to add one more caution, which is also not immediately obvious. Your attorney is not your friend. He or she is an officer of the court, and your case is not important enough for your attorney to risk being blackballed against practicing in a particular court. So any discussions about taking recourse, or sending materials to a friend ahead of time, should not take place with the attorney you have hired. Rather, you should consider an attorney in another jurisdiction, and another state if possible. The attorney then is not able to give you legal advice, but you can learn of general processes and acquire some resources to increase your chances of successful recourse when the system fails.

If you asked why a person with no standing in a case should proceed against a judge who misbehaves, I’ll refer back to the original theme. Notice the words were "People Perish for Lack of Knowledge" and not "A Person Perishes for Lack of Knowledge." The societal impact of court proceedings, and of the behavior of all court officers, is far greater than the outcome of a single case. Therefore, while you may think a judge who misbehaves is none of your business, a misbehaving judge is EVERYBODY’S business. If a defective judge knows he or she no longer enjoys the protection of anonymity or intimidation, the quality of our court system may be restored to a level resembling the original intention of our nation’s founders.

Brandy Schneider’s case was not isolated. Change a few details and you have thousands of other incidents that occurred in just the last ten years. The breakdown is not only serious; it is progressive. But the good news is that it is reversible, if only we will take the measures that are available to us.
Reblog this post [with Zemanta]
Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...

Disclaimer

The opinions and information expressed in the individual posts do not necessarily reflect the opinions of each contributor of "Time's Up!" nor the opinion of the blog owner and administrator. The comments are the opinion and property of the individuals who leave them on the posts and do not express the opinion of the authors, contributors or the blog owner and administrator.