Showing posts with label cognitive. Show all posts
Showing posts with label cognitive. Show all posts

Monday, August 2, 2010

Silver Alert!


By Cynthia Caron

Many ask LostNMissing Inc “What exactly is a Silver Alert?”  Most are under the assumption that Silver Alerts are specifically for the elderly who have wandered away from home.  In reality it is thankfully much more!  Many states include not only our seniors but anyone who may have cognitive impairments or developmentally disabled.  Our younger generation, usually over the age of 14, who have autism may also qualify should they wander and go missing.

The Silver Alert does vary from State to State and not all US States have adopted a Silver Alert program.  Some states, such as Connecticut, will also include those with mental or emotional disorders such as bipolar and schizophrenia.  Because Silver Alerts are relatively new in the United States many police agencies and the general public will need educated regarding the program provided by their individual state.  As of this writing, approximately 24 states are active participants in this program.  Many more states are in the process of presenting their state legislatures to petition for Silver Alerts or are in the process of implementing a program.

(*)26 states have Silver Alert or similar programs targeting missing seniors. 18 states have missing senior recovery programs that are formally called “Silver Alert”:
  • Arkansas
  • Connecticut
  • Florida
  • Illinois
  • Indiana
  • Kansas
  • Louisiana
  • Maine
  • Maryland
  • Mississippi
  • New Jersey
  • North Carolina
  • Oklahoma
  • Rhode Island
  • South Carolina
  • Tennessee
  • Texas
  • West Virginia
Additionally, 8 states have programs to help locate missing seniors that are not officially called “Silver Alert” but contain criteria similar to existing Silver Alert programs:
  • Alabama, Missing Senior Alert
  • Delaware, Gold Alert
  • Colorado, Missing Senior Citizen Alert
  • Georgia, Mattie’s Call
  • Kentucky, Golden Alert
  • New Hampshire, Missing Senior Citizen Alert
  • Ohio, Missing Adult Alert
  • Virginia, Senior Alert
Plus, 8 states have missing persons alert systems with broader criteria than conventional Silver Alert programs. These missing person alerts apply to larger categories of endangered persons, or apply to all missing people, regardless of age or impairment:
  • Arizona, Endangered Persons Alert
  • Minnesota, Brandon’s Law
  • Missouri, Endangered Person Advisory
  • Montana, Missing and Endangered Persons Advisory
  • New Mexico, Endangered Person Advisory
  • South Dakota, Endangered Persons Advisory
  • Utah, Endangered Person Advisory
  • Wyoming, Endangered Person Advisory
10 states have considered Silver Alert legislation in the past year:
  • California
  • Hawaii
  • Iowa
  • Massachusetts-House passes Bill to Instate Program. (July 2010)
  • Michigan
  • Nevada
  • New York
  • Oregon
  • Pennsylvania
  • Wisconsin

Local law enforcement must activate a Silver Alert by following the criteria set forth in their state.  States that do not have a present Silver Alert may be close to implementing.  Massachusetts just voted and the bill is before the Senate and will then need signed by the Governor.   States that have adopted the Silver Alert have patterned their criteria by the Silver Alert Initiative which can be read here:  http://www.nasua.org/pdf/Silver%20Alert%20Initiatives%20in%20the%20states.pdf


The public can check with their local Alzheimer’s Association to find out if their state is close to having a program in place, or to even volunteer to assist with helping to get the program implemented.  Most all states that do have active programs  have been very successful in helping to locate those who have wandered away from home.  If you know a family who has a loved one who may potentially wander away from home, or have cognitive disorders, do help spread the word about the Silver Alert Program as the better educated those families are, the better chance that should their love one wander from home be located safely.  There are many programs that enable families to be proactive and register a potential “wanderer” ahead of time so that should they go missing a simple phone call and the police can have all the pertinent information on hand regarding the missing person. This can save valuable time and enable the police to actively pursue looking for their family member.  Some programs which offer free registrations are Missing Patient.Com, www.missingpatient.com , another is a private company (not a government agency) called National Silver Alert Programhttp://nationalsilveralert.org/.  There are also numerous products available to help keep track of those who may wander from GPS devices to alarms and even special shoes that have a GPS device installed in the heels.

Family and private caretakers, facilities, home health agencies and group homes should all be aware if a program exists in their state and also have something in place to help monitor their family member, or resident, as well as have as much information readily available including a recent photograph (preferable a head and shoulder photo) of those in their care.  Minutes count when a loved one with a cognitive disorder wanders away from home.


(*)updated information on statistics gathered from Wikipedia http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Silver_Alert


Cynthia L. Caron
President/Founder
LostNMissing, Inc.
PH: 
603.548.6548
www.lostnmissing.com

Enhanced by Zemanta

Friday, May 28, 2010

Tunnel Vision Deja Vu



By Randy McCall

Last week I found an interesting online article, posted on a Psychology Today blog by Mark White. This particular article, titled Tunnel Vision in the Criminal Justice System examined the work of several professors, which detailed how false convictions happen when investigators and prosecutors unconsciously decide that a particular individual must be the perpetrator.

In essence, the article says that law enforcement and prosecution, having committed to the idea that they have the criminal in custody, then views all following investigations, collected evidence and interrogations through a biased lens.
Findley uses this case as an example of tunnel vision in the criminal justice system, identifying mistakes made at each stage of the process that can be traced to common cognnitive biases. In Findley's words, "tunnel vision is the product of a variety of cognitive distortions, such as confirmation bias, hindsight bias, and outcome bias, which can impede accuracy in what we perceive and in how we interpret what we perceive" ("Tunnel Vision," p. 6).
Some quick definitions would be helpful here:

Confirmation Bias: from the article "Confirmation bias describes the natural human tendency to interpret new information in a way that confirms our pre-existing beliefs, to remember previous events in a way that confirms those beliefs, and to discount or discard information that challenges them"

Hindsight Bias: from the article "Hindsight bias describes another natural tendency to regard a past event as inevitable, or at least much likely than originally thought, after it is confirmed by later information. Otherwise known as the "knew-it-all-along" effect, it stems from the way we construct our memories of events, using all of the information gathered since the original occurrence to arrive at a much more definite causal chain of events than is objectively warranted."

Outcome Bias: An error made in evaluating the quality of a decision when the outcome of that decision is already known.

We can sum these up much more simply - if the article author will forgive me for the vast oversimplification - as:
  • I believe what I've seen
  • I've seen it all before
  • It's always worked out for the best.
I was particularly interested in the list of cognitive distortions listed above, as - having my own cognitive biases - it immediately occurred to me that we could apply the Tunnel Vision effect to crime victims in-and-out-of the criminal justice system.

Let's call it Tunnel Vision Deja Vu.

Within some elements of society - and certainly within the judicial and reparation systems - there are a series of biases or beliefs about crime victims. Crime victims, viewed through this lens, are all assigned the same general thoughts, motivations and desires, despite their drastically different experiences, personalities, ethnic or cultural backgrounds, and religious or ethical persuasions.

Some of the more common stereotypes, which I'm sure you've read or seen before: Victims are weak, are damaged goods, are somehow at fault for - or caused - their own victimization, are always exaggerating, are attention seekers, are solely interested in vengeance, will always seek maximum penalties, are only interested in money, and so on.

Precisely how these beliefs developed is the topic for a much larger article. I can take a few educated guesses, however.

In some cases it's simply a matter of psychological self defense... for example, the belief that victims caused their own victimization springs from a refusal to believe that: "something bad could happen to me... I would never do that, therefore I am safe, and they were stupid".

In other cases, it could be the result of a very negative experience by judicial staff with a few victims. It's only human nature to remember the worst, not the best, about people, just as a defense: remember "Once burned, twice shy"? Of course, these staff are going to be the ones training new staff members, and sharing their experiences with peers. It doesn't take long for the worst possible examples to be passed around between offices, courts or regions. Over the years the few negative examples from different offices build up and become the base norm. This field is also particular susceptible to the "We know what's best for you" and "It's always worked out for the best" viewpoints. It makes life so much easier than tailor-making solutions.

Finally, some of these viewpoints can be based in the systemic policy of an agency, as is shown in great detail in Adding Insult to Injury, a report by the Ombudsman of Ontario on the Provincial Criminal Injuries Compensation Board, as well as in a UK report on their national Criminal Injuries Compensation Authority, Compensating Victims of Violent Crime. Both these reports found policies having staff to stonewall victim applications, to not give full information, and to treat all applications as suspicious (e.g they only want money), all in an effort to pay out as little compensation as possible. Unfortunately, what starts out as a policy, ends up as a bias.

Thus, while Tunnel Vision can drive innocent people into prison, for victims Tunnel Vision Deja Vu creates entire mindsets which then try to force victims of crime into pre-set molds, prepared expectations, assembly-line solutions, and pre-determined successful outcomes.

Time society took another look, don't you think?
Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...

Disclaimer

The opinions and information expressed in the individual posts do not necessarily reflect the opinions of each contributor of "Time's Up!" nor the opinion of the blog owner and administrator. The comments are the opinion and property of the individuals who leave them on the posts and do not express the opinion of the authors, contributors or the blog owner and administrator.